Main » 2006»October»5 » Janis Joplin (Big Brother & The Holding company) - 1968 - Live at Winterland
Janis Joplin (Big Brother & The Holding company) - 1968 - Live at Winterland
11:25
Janis Joplin (Big Brother & The Holding company) - 1968 - Live at Winterland
Great live album! But, unfortunately (or fortunately), Janis live and Janis in the studio are exactly the same thing.
Track listing: 01) Down On Me (version 1) 02) Flower In The Sun 03) I Need A Man To Love 04) Bye Bye Baby 05) Easy Rider 06) Combination Of The Two 07) Farewell Song 08) Piece Of My Heart 09) Catch Me Daddy 10) Magic Of Love 11) Summertime 12) Light Is Faster Than Sound 13) Ball And Chain 14)
Down On Me (version 2)
Big Brother mostly built their reputation on live
shows, playing lots of venues in San Francisco and all over the States,
so that they didn't even bother about recording their new material
properly in the studio (Cheap Thrills mostly consists of live
material). Therefore, this album can easily serve you as a good
substitute for both of their original LP's, as well as for the later
Farewell Song: practically all of Janis' big hits and lots of smaller,
but none the less interesting tunes are included. The CD is actually a
complete recording of their two shows played in Mid-April at
Winterland, San Francisco, with everything to recommend it and
practically nothing to despise about it. The sound quality is quite
tolerable, maybe even excellent at times. The only possible pick is
that there are two versions of 'Down On Me' on here - opening and
closing the album; but this, together with all the stage banter, even
the most boring bits of it, being preserved, only confirms the idea
that both of the sets are included in their completeness - a thing
rarely cared about by record companies.
Chronologically, this is
the band's next album after the self-titled one, and it's really
important, because this is the era when Janis finally made the ultimate
transgression and got completely loose on stage. Both shows are rather
short, with seven songs in each performance, but it's fairly obvious
every such show had to leave the poor girl completely exhausted, and
not just because it was hard to get her lungs overcome the double
guitar distortion, of course. This is where Janis becomes the
unstoppable live monster, the 'give-it-yer-all' epiphany of American
rock, together with Hendrix.
The problem with the album, of
course, is that you really don't need it if you've already got the
original LP's. Even 'Summertime' sounds catastrophically close to the
studio original; what can be said then of tunes like 'Combination Of
The Two' whose original versions were live as well? I mean, you already
heard 'Combination Of The Two' live on Cheap Thrills (recorded at the
Fillmore, by the way, just a couple of feet and a couple of dates away
from Winterland), why should you bother about hearing it here? And, in
fact, the version of 'Ball And Chain' used on Cheap Thrills seems to be
the very one found on here. Well... actually, the liner notes say 'all
tracks previously unreleased', so I suppose the tapes for Cheap Thrills
were ultimately taken off some other live recording, but that's up to
the qualified Janis specialist to really determine.